Crate & Barrel opened its first furniture store back in 1962. They now have more than 100 stores in the United States and Canada, not including their franchises in other parts of the world. Their other businesses include CB2, Crate & Kids and also Hudson Grace, which they acquired in 2019.
With huge operations run by more than 8,000 employees, Crate & Barrel offers furniture with quality craftsmanship and in stylish designs. Their sofas are known for simple, modern designs as well as exceptional comfort.
We’ve been designing Crate & Barrel replacement sofa covers for years now, and based on what we’ve learnt, this is our list of what we consider to be the 5 best Crate & Barrel sofas:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Crate & Barrel Lounge Sofa
2. Crate & Barrel Petrie Midcentury Sofa
3. Crate & Barrel Willow II Slipcovered Sofa
4. Crate & Barrel Barrett II Track Arm Sofa
5. Crate & Barrel Gather Sofa
1. Crate & Barrel Lounge Sofa
Price: (2023) $1,749 – $2,299
| What’s good | What’s not so good |
| Durable Lasts for years due to kiln-dried wood that prevents the wood from warping | Cushions are easily squashed Needs daily fluffing to maintain plump cushions |
| Comfortable The cushions are soft and great to lounge on | |
| Stylish Its simple yet modern design matches well with contemporary home interiors |
Seats up to 4 adults (may vary according to person’s size)
Width: Available from 73” to 105”
Who is it for: The Crate & Barrel Lounge Sofa is the perfect sofa for a family with 3-4 people. If you love watching movies, TV shows or anything that’s on screen with the people you love, lounge on this sofa for hours without feeling the need to get up.
Feeling of the first sit: The cushions are so soft – definitely made for relaxing. Don’t you ever think of catching up on work here, it’s not going to work. Maybe that’s why it deserves to be in our 5 Best Crate & Barrel Sofas list. We prefer chilling than working on the sofa, to be honest.
Warranty: Crate & Barrel does not advertise any warranty on their website, but they do have a return policy for items within 90 days of receipt.
What we think: The simple and modern design of this couch is what we like most about it. It’s not an attention-seeker, yet it is present enough to be noticeable by whoever walks into the space. The sturdy frame and neatly sewn covers also portray Crate & Barrel’s fine craftsmanship. Not only does it look good, it’s plush and just great for chilling on the sofa.
2. Crate & Barrel Petrie Midcentury Sofa
Price: (2023) $1,699 – $2,299
| What’s good | What’s not so good |
| Stylish Sleek design with tufted buttons are the perfect representation of mid-century modern | Loose buttons Buttons may become loose due to high traffic |
| Durable Lasts for years thanks to its kiln-dried hardwood that prevents warping | |
| Good for entertaining Upright seating allows guests to sit comfortably |
Seats up to 4 adults (may vary according to person’s size)
Width: Available from 65” to 100”
Who is it for: From a family of 2 adults to a family of 4 people, this couch comes in 4 widths to cater to families of various sizes. Another good thing about the Petrie Midcentury is that it can be used as a casual couch or even at more formal settings such as the office. Because of its style, if you are into mid-century modern or have a home of this style, you’ve got to get it!
Feeling of the first sit: The first look had me thinking that it’s probably much more suitable in an office setting compared to a living space. The first sit further affirmed my thought when I sat on it – it’s firm, but soft enough for comfort, which means it’s also great for hosting clients whenever they come over to the office.
Warranty: Crate & Barrel does not advertise any warranty on their website, but they do have a return policy for items within 90 days of receipt.
What we think: Although the Petrie Midcentury is more of an upright sofa than one for lounging, the midcentury modern style is a sure-winner. I mean, look at how sleek it is. Once you place this in your home, it changes everything. Say hello to classy!
3. Crate & Barrel Willow II Slipcovered Sofa
Price: (2023) $1,949 – $2,499
| What’s good | What’s not so good |
| Easy to clean Machine-washable sofa covers | Hard cushions Cushions could be on the firmer side for some people |
| Responsible design Made from wood sourced from responsibly managed forests under the FSC® certification | |
| Armrest height Track arms sit at the right height for resting your arms |
Seats up to 4 adults (may vary according to person’s size)
Width: Available in 74”, 84” and 103”
Who is it for: The model with the smallest width of 74” easily fits 3 people, so we say this sofa is ideal when there are 3 to 4 people in the family. The Willow II is also a must-buy for people who are in love with the coastal design. The relaxed design of the couch, if paired with the hero Solana Fabric in White, is the quintessential coastal look that you can’t get enough of.
Feeling of the first sit: Despite being a little firmer than the discontinued Willow, it’s still pretty good. The couch is bouncy, but also lets you sink into the seat, so that you can lounge there all day long.
Warranty: Crate & Barrel does not advertise any warranty on their website, but they do have a return policy for items within 90 days of receipt.
What we think: If you judge a sofa by its cover, the Willow II gives you exactly what it looks like on the outside – relaxing. With cushion shapes that have a laidback feel, you’re invited to lounge on the Willow II any day, any time, preferably near the sandy beaches.
4. Crate & Barrel Barrett II Track Arm Sofa
Price: (2023) $1,499 – $2,049
| What’s good | What’s not so good |
| Durable Kiln-dried hardwood used for sofa frame prevents warping of wood so that it can last for years | Hard cushions Back cushions could be on the firmer side for some people |
| Supportive cushions Polyfoam cushions with 7.5 gauge sinuous springs make it firm and eliminates sagging | |
| Stylish The modern style meets the needs of an interior with a contemporary design |
Seats up to 4 adults (may vary according to person’s size)
Width: Available from 70” to 103”
Who is it for: The Crate and Barrett II comes in 4 different sizes that can seat a family of 2 to 4 people. It’s also for people who prefer a modern-looking sofa that also looks very sophisticated. The high back cushions offer better back support, so it’s suitable for people who are less of a lounger.
Feeling of the first sit: Its seat cushions are firm, so they don’t provide the sink-in feeling like the Crate & Barrel Lounge Deep Sofa does. That’s not a con to me because I prefer feeling like I’m actually sitting on the sofa, instead of sinking into it.
Warranty: Crate & Barrel does not advertise any warranty on their website, but they do have a return policy for items within 90 days of receipt.
What we think: It’s great for contemporary home interior, especially when the owner likes to host parties. This is because the firm seats provide great seating for guests when they come over because nobody’s going to sink in and spill their drinks. Although we’ve actually got a solution for that – Performance Weave sofa covers. They would look great in office settings as well, we can totally envision your clients sitting there comfortably while having a discussion with you.
5. Crate & Barrel Gather Sofa
Price: (2023) $1,749 – $2,099
| What’s good | What’s not so good |
| Durable Lasts for years due to kiln-dried wood that prevents the wood from warping | Average seat height Could use a little more seat height for taller people |
| Stylish Its simple yet modern design matches well with contemporary home interiors | Cushions are easily squashed Needs daily fluffing to maintain plump cushions |
| GREENGUARD Gold Certified Low chemical emission which contributes to cleaner indoor air for you and your family |
Seats up to 4 adults (may vary according to person’s size)
Width: Available in 76”, 88” and 98”
Who is it for: With its GREENGUARD Gold certification, the low chemical emission means it’s safer for families with children. If you have young kids and would want cleaner indoor air, it’s good to go with the Gather sofa. Although the widest size can fit up to 4 adults, space could be a little bit tight compared to other sofas that are at least 100” wide.
Feeling of the first sit: Firm at the beginning, but it will eventually become softer as you break in the cushions. Even though the seat height is low, the back cushions are actually really high. If you’re on the taller side, you’d be able to get full support on your shoulders and back.
Warranty: Crate & Barrel does not advertise any warranty on their website, but they do have a return policy for items within 90 days of receipt.
What we think: Firstly, we really like its design! It’s slim, with sleek and modern lines that fit well into our tastes in à la mode aesthetics. ✨ Its bouncy cushions are also on point. Just like its name suggests, it’s a sofa that you can gather on with people you’re comfortable with and have a good stay-in session. That, my friends, means you’re comfortable inside out.
Which Crate & Barrel sofa caught your eye? We hope you find the best Crate & Barrel sofa for yourself, and let us know if you have any questions.
A fan of lounging on deep, deep sofas? Take a look at our review of Crate & Barrel’s best deep couches:
Crate & Barrel’s Best Deep Couches
Things to note about Crate & Barrel: For products that are not in stock, be prepared to wait for months until you receive it. If you’re not in a hurry and are patient enough, we don’t see why you can’t order items that are off the shelves.